[Cop_Out]

So, what's a better size, Commander or Government? What's the hives opinion on this?
Thanks!
C

 

[WWB]

Depends on the purpose and what you prefer me I prefer either a Government or a CCO for some reason I have had a half dozen commanders and they just dont do much for me..

 

[Mike A]

I like the Government for shooting & the Commander for carry.
Big weight difference, but my Government models shoot better.

 

[ZoidMeister]

Papa Bear, Momma Bear, Baby Bear . . . .

 

[Hairtrigger]

One of each!
They all have a purpose

 

[Au Jus in Bello]

They're identical except for 3/4" at the front end. To me, that balances a little better, points a little easier, and clears holster a little faster. In all of those, however, the difference is minimal. The trade is the 4-1/4" commander length is the minimum the 1911 design will function using a bushing, so you've reduced the reliability threshold slightly.

 

[gun_fan111]

Government slide with a commander grip works best for me

 

[WC145]

I have both, have come to prefer a Commander for general carry, a little shorter, a little faster out of the holster, a little more comfortable when sitting in the car. But, most of my 1911s are Gov'ts, some of them also get carried, depending on the circumstances, and I usually us a 5" in competition. You have to try them all and figure out what works best for you.

 

[RatBikeRod]

What’s better, beats or bears?

Really its what you like most. Personally, pretty much everything I own (1911 or not) is commander length because I want the option of carrying them all! And yes, you can carry a Gov sized 1911 just fine, I just prefer the look, feel and balance of a commmander.

Really up to you.

 

[Yoemen66]

I like the government for either shooting or carry. Your size will play into that a bit. I am 6'4" and the commander just feels small when I have messed with them. Of course, I also like having magwells on my guns for the added heft.

 

[pistolpete]

I'm a little more accurate with a 5" gun but my favorite shooter is a Ruger CMD. For carry a lightweight Commander. The lightweight is a little snappy in .45 but manageable. I have a new 9MM Valkyrie Commander, it may become my favorite shooter, we'll see.
The Commander is faster out of the holster, I really like the CMD.

 

[Babboonbobo]

I’m sticking with commander and cco versions. I’ve been thinking about releasing my government sizes into the wild but probably won’t!

 

[stlgecko]

I change my opinion weekly. I have all 3 sizes and enjoy them all.

 

[Jollyroger1]

Same as @stlgecko. I like them all and rotate often. Lol

 

[TheCollector]

one potato.. two potatoes...three potatoes....four

 

[ORShooter]

I have a new found love affair with my Ruger LW CMD and have an all stainless Ruger CMD on the way. I like the feel and weight better than the full size. To me, 3/4" can be felt and does make a difference.

 

[ORShooter]

one potato.. two potatoes...three potatoes....four

Sounds like breakfast! What time we eat'n?

 

[DD_USMC]

Government slide with a commander grip works best for me

Please clarify....LOL or confused...not sure of your meaning.

 

[BigSkyGuy]

Same as @stlgecko. I like them all and rotate often. Lol

What these gents said.

I used to favor the Commander size, but then started feeling more love for the G'ovt...then I tried out a CCO...I wouldn't want to have to pick between any of 'em!

Todd

 

[BigSkyGuy]

I’m sticking with commander and cco versions. I’ve been thinking about releasing my government sizes into the wild but probably won’t!

You let me know if you decide to turn that 5" 10mm Wilson out...

Thx,
Todd