I'm struggling with this decision fellow addicts. I need some enabling. I mean convincing. I mean advice..... I think. First, some qualifications: I have some nice MSR's but that's only because I'm half-a-crazy-prepper. I primarily shoot pistol, and conceal carry daily. I've had about 200 hours of professional training in various disciplines, and I'm at the range practically every weekend for the last 12 years. My EDC for the past few years has been some P320 variation in 9mm... or more recently a 45ACP 1911 Commander from Dan Wesson, SA or other semi-custom. Years past I carried and shot P226 and P229 DA/SA exclusively, but sold them all off when the P320's came out. I am not a collector, I cannot afford nor justify "Safe Queens" and every gun I own has a role, a purpose and gets carried and shot heavily. Here's the issue. I LOVE shooting 1911. I love them. I get stupid with the tweaking and customizing of them and it's a damn money pit that never leaves me feeling satisfied, just gives me more ideas and new things I want to customize or add-on to. They're big, they're heavy, they don't carry easily on my skinny 31" waist, and now that I've just picked up a pair of brand new P220 Legion SAO's... I cannot justify having BOTH them AND two somewhat expensive 1911s. I only need 2 fullsize .45acp pistols, and my OCD (and training regimen) dictates they be the same operating platform. I need to sell one or the other; the 1911s or the P220 Legions SAO's. I know keeping the Legions is the practical option, as they'll serve just as well and I'll pocket a LOT more cash selling the 1911s. The Legions are less expensive, they conceal-carry the same as the Commander 1911s in terms of size and are MUCH lighter.... they're 100% reliable and hell-and-back tough. They wear the same flat trigger and Xray sights as my several iterations of P320. I'm not a good enough shooter to leverage whatever increased accuracy beyond 50yds the 1911s might have over the Legions. I shoot them both equally well after a few practice rounds. But there's just something about the 1911s I love. In short - Have you every struggled between a 1911 or P-Series SiG as your Primary in a given role? What did you decide and how did it work out? "Keep all of them" / "Keep one of each" / "Buy a CZ!" etc are not options. I need to clear some cash and dont need any extras. That's the way of things. If you haven't guessed already... I'm getting married. I posted earlier this year about this kind of dilemma, rotating your EDC... now it's time to vote! Enable me Addicts!