1911 Firearm Addicts banner

Springfield Prodigy 5”

2408 Views 21 Replies 9 Participants Last post by  Dump1567
4
Just picked up a 5” Prodigy and I’m guessing this should be from the most recent production batch since the dealer just got it back in stock. I was a little worried based on some of the reviews when the gun first came out. I’m happy to report that this latest example seems very well made. It came with a 12lb recoil spring and there’s no hang up on the disconnector when the slide comes forward. Checked the extractor tension and it was set correctly from the factory. I went ahead and installed a hammer, sear, and disconnector set from Extreme Engineering. Without any stoning I’m getting a 4.5-4.75lb pull no creep. I re-used the stock thumb safety and that required some minor fitting. I also replaced the slide stop with an Atlas… stock slide stop pin measured around .199 and the Atlas slide stop was just ever so slightly bigger at .1995 and that was enough for it to bind so the factory slide stop was fitted very tight. Ended up using Flitz on the barrel feet and 400grit sandpaper on the slide stop pin… the sandpaper didn’t even remove the finish on the slide stop pin. But all that was enough and now there’s no binding and the slide cycles very smoothly. I also put in an Atlas flat trigger, 20lb mainspring, and swapped the firing pin spring to a regular extra power one.

Overall I’m very happy with it and looks like Springfield Armory is listening to its customers. Including the pistol, sight plate, fire control parts and Dawson tool less guide rod I have around $1600 into it. I also own a few Staccato’s so I’m looking forward to comparing them side by side. I prefer the grip on the Prodigy way better than the stock Staccato grips and they’re a lot easier to remove also.
Air gun Wood Trigger Gun barrel Gun accessory

Air gun Trigger Wood Gun barrel Gun accessory

Automotive tire Tire Machine Automotive design Auto part

Automotive tire Rim Automotive design Fender Gun accessory
See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 5
1 - 20 of 22 Posts
Looking good! Let us know how she runs when you get time to put the mods through their paces.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
Congrats. I've done similar Mods to my 4.25", but it worked fine out of the box. I had issues with the ambi hanging-up as a lefty, so I replaced it with a Staccato. I like the factory grip too, but wanted something different. I still need to look into a wider slide stop.

Kduly can stipple your Staccato grips if you don't like the texture. I just sent him another C2 grip to do.

See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 5
2
The ambi on mine out of the box felt really good. No hanging up and very tight with the ambi. With the new sear and hammer I had to remove some material on the safety to get it to fit. It still has a very nice click when you engage and disengage it. So no worries about accidentally engaging it when shooting…. although with how heavy this gun is I can’t imagine it would recoil very much.

I actually have all my Staccato‘s grips done by Boresight Solutions since they’re local to me…. Also have one with a grip I bought from Extreme Grips. The Prodigy stock grips are good enough for me that I don’t feel like I need to spend the extra money “fixing“ it. 😁. So I guess that’s another point in the value proposition column for the Prodigy. BTW at least to me, the Prodigy grips feel thinner and less chunky than the stock Staccato grips. The Boresight and Extreme stippling definitely make the stock Staccato grips feel thinner and less blocky.

Air gun Trigger Wood Gun barrel Gun accessory

Hood Wood Bumper Automotive exterior Automotive design
See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 3
Also for wider slide stops EGW just came out with one also but might require some more fitting since their pin diameter is spec’d at .200. I went with the Atlas because theirs is spec’d at .199 which figure would drop in but on my gun it still needed some fitting to make it work. Interestingly I have an older Staccato that has a .201 pin and a newer one that has a .199 pin. I just ordered one from Dawson that I‘m going to put on a BUL SAS II Ultralight 3.25” so hopefully it’s .199 so I don’t have to mess with it. If it’s .199 it would probably just drop in on the Prodigy. 10-8 also has a slide stop which is the same shape as the Staccato but they spec their pin at .200. Those are the only ones I know of that have a slightly wider ledge and still look like a standard slide stop. I’m not big on how some of these extended slide stops look.
Also for wider slide stops EGW just came out with one also but might require some more fitting since their pin diameter is spec’d at .200. I went with the Atlas because theirs is spec’d at .199 which figure would drop in but on my gun it still needed some fitting to make it work. Interestingly I have an older Staccato that has a .201 pin and a newer one that has a .199 pin. I just ordered one from Dawson that I‘m going to put on a BUL SAS II Ultralight 3.25” so hopefully it’s .199 so I don’t have to mess with it. If it’s .199 it would probably just drop in on the Prodigy. 10-8 also has a slide stop which is the same shape as the Staccato but they spec their pin at .200. Those are the only ones I know of that have a slightly wider ledge and still look like a standard slide stop. I’m not big on how some of these extended slide stops look.
I just got the new prodigy slide stop from EGW and it’s definitely not a drop-in part as advertised. It’s too big! I got it in there but it’s so tight it’s not letting the barrel unlock! It needs some fitting for sure.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
So it really seems like for it to have a chance of dropping in that it needs to be .199. Also I noticed on 10-8’s description of their Staccato slide stop it says it’s the OEM one from 2018-2020 so now it makes sense why my older one has a larger diameter pin while my newer one’s are .199. When I get the new Staccato slide stop from Dawson I’ll check to see if they drop in… I have an incoming 4.25” Prodigy so I can check it on an untouched barrel.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
My 10-8 i just bought used dropped in with no issues. The SS had no marks on it prior to installing.
  • Like
Reactions: 2
I'm guessing that has more to do with the variation in how each barrel is fitted by Springfield.

My 10-8 i just bought used dropped in with no issues. The SS had no marks on it prior to installing.
I'm guessing that has more to do with the variation in how each barrel is fitted by Springfield.
Probably so as none of the 10-8s ive ever owned fit in any baers ive ever owned. Wont even go in the hole.
I have the same issue with my slide stop from EGW. What would be the best way to fit it?


I just got the new prodigy slide stop from EGW and it’s definitely not a drop-in part as advertised. It’s too big! I got it in there but it’s so tight it’s not letting the barrel unlock! It needs some fitting for sure.
Ran the first 200 rounds yesterday. Federal 115gr white box FMJ Training Ammo. Zero malfunctions. Brass ejection was consistent and where it’s supposed to be. Recoil impulse was smooth and shot fairly flat. I’m going to try an 11lb recoil spring once I get 1,000 rounds though it. 12lbs at least for me still feels a little bit snappy when going back into battery. I am using Staccato magazines since I have plenty of those laying around. Basically to summarize, the stock recoil spring is 12lbs so that didn’t change. I changed the hammer spring to 20lbs and to avoid light primer strIke’s I changed the factory super extra power firing pin spring to a regular XP firing pin spring. Atlas slide stop required minor firing and re-used the stock ambi safety which also required some fitting to work properly with the Extreme Engineering Tactical II hammer, Tactical Sear, and disconnector. And also used the Dawson Tool less guide rod’s for Springfields.

So for this particular Prodigy, Springfield did a very nice job at the factory. I’ve got a 4.25” that I’m going to do the same mods to and hopefully I’ll get that knocked out in a couple of weeks and see if that one is as good as the 5” one I just shot.
See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 1
My 10-8 i just bought used dropped in with no issues. The SS had no marks on it prior to installing.
My very early release 4.25" Prodigy is 100% good to go with the 10-8 Slide Stop without any fitment or function issues. The hammer, ambi-safety, trigger, grip safety, mag release, disconnector, extractor, and overall fitment has been excellent thus far, as I guess I was one of the "luck one's" with my 1911DS. Fortunate to be a little over 3,000rds w/o problems or modifications except for a short break-in period w/ a 12lbs spring from Wilson Combat and now back to the 9lbs spring. I did a very thorough break-in of the 17 and 20 round mags prior to their use, and I've only installed the Springfield optic mounting plate for a HS407co and a TLR-1 HL. If I start to have any internal issues, I'll look at the stuff from Atlas and others that have 4.25" specific gear. Waiting to see if 10-8 or Dawson will release a one-piece or tool-less guide rod for the 4.25" Prodigy. This is a very nice shooter for the price and for my use on the range and in the field.
Automotive tire Sewing machine Motor vehicle Wood Bumper
See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 5
My 4.25" Prodigy is 100% good to go with the 10-8 Slide Stop without any fitment or function issues.
That's great. Need Hilton to get more in stock. Need one for my 5". He emailed back saying he had no ETA.
I know he's got the stainless stops on hand, as I just ordered one to try out on my DW Specialist.

Check with Ed Brown for a blued 9mm edged slide stop, as they apparently make a similar slide stop as 10-8's in size, shape, and function according to our unit armorer: Tactical Edge Forged Slide Stop | Ed Brown Products, Inc.
Atlas has a Prodigy specific 4.25” tool less guide rod.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
Which would be better off in the long run, the Atlas or the EGW, and which needs the fewest additional items (i.e. reverse plug, pins, etc.)?

atlasgunworks.com
Springfield Prodigy 4.25" Guide Rod Kit (egwguns.com)

THX
The Atlas is similar to the Dawson style tool less guide rod and it’s sized for the reverse plug that comes with the Prodigy. The EGW is a one piece with a take down hole so you still need to use a paper clip.
  • Love
Reactions: 1
Order placed with Atlas, many thanks! (y)
  • Like
Reactions: 1
Ran the first 200 rounds yesterday. Federal 115gr white box FMJ Training Ammo. Zero malfunctions. Brass ejection was consistent and where it’s supposed to be. Recoil impulse was smooth and shot fairly flat. I’m going to try an 11lb recoil spring once I get 1,000 rounds though it. 12lbs at least for me still feels a little bit snappy when going back into battery. I am using Staccato magazines since I have plenty of those laying around. Basically to summarize, the stock recoil spring is 12lbs so that didn’t change. I changed the hammer spring to 20lbs and to avoid light primer strIke’s I changed the factory super extra power firing pin spring to a regular XP firing pin spring. Atlas slide stop required minor firing and re-used the stock ambi safety which also required some fitting to work properly with the Extreme Engineering Tactical II hammer, Tactical Sear, and disconnector. And also used the Dawson Tool less guide rod’s for Springfields.

So for this particular Prodigy, Springfield did a very nice job at the factory. I’ve got a 4.25” that I’m going to do the same mods to and hopefully I’ll get that knocked out in a couple of weeks and see if that one is as good as the 5” one I just shot.
Thanks for sharing. Had some light strikes on my 5” so will have to try that out to see if it improves
1 - 20 of 22 Posts
Top