1911 Firearm Addicts banner

I think I need a limited Optics Pistol

4.4K views 44 replies 25 participants last post by  ddc  
#1 ·
Or I want a new limited Optics pistol. I'm currently using a shadow to Orange which has been an amazing pistol, but I feel the trigger is slowing me down.

My top choices right now would be a staccato XL, voodoo priest or MPA. I've also wondered if I should look at the dwx, if I go that route, I would have to send it to Cajun for them to do a trigger job on it.

The only pistol I've shot from the above list would be a Staccato XL. How does it compare to the others?

Is there something else I should put on the list? I would like to keep it in the same ballpark price
 
#4 ·
You have some good choices there. I'd highly consider the new MPA v2 LOC as its essentially an Atlas Artemis clone at half the price (sight block and all).


Get the discount code on PRS to get 15% off of your purchase at MPA, brings that gun down into the $3800 range.

(I don't own one, I have no relationship with MPA, I just think its a cool gun and may be a unique combination of features and price in the LO marketplace)
 
#7 ·
many consider the Atlas Artemis the ultimate LO pistol (this side of Infinity and a couple of others I guess). MPA is doing something very interesting making this gun for that price. (similarly the seem to have recently launched an XC clone for similarly good value).

Use the search function here, there is a thread wherein a bunch of guys here are discussing these new MPA offerings and their very good value Open guns.
 
#8 ·
What is your classification in USPSA? There are quite a lot of choices for LO gun. I use an Atlas Athena or a 5.4 Inch Infinity Sight Tracker. The Infinity is more accurate but a bit heavier so a little more sluggish. I have a few LO guns coming next year so I will be most likely using an Infinity LO Bushing gun.

Getting a tricked out high end 2011 as your LO gun probably wont make you much better. You may mentally think you are better, and that may be half your battle lol
 
#12 ·
I own a 9mm Atlas Titan (5”) and love it. After a lot of forum reading (when I should be dry firing) it seems like the most ideal setup has a shorter(lighter) slide such as a 4.6” Athena or one of the barrel block guns depending on how heavy you want the front end. Plenty of people are just fine with a lightened 5” slide however. It seems like Vudoo has an excellent reputation for quality and is probably a best value in high end 2011’s. Sometimes used Atlas’ become available. I recently got outbid on an almost new Athena V2 that sold for just under $5000. Any of the guns you mentioned are likely to run great and not hold you back IMHO. I doubt the Orange is holding you back much, but I like shiny new things also.
 
#13 · (Edited)
To offer an opinion on the the Stacatto XL part of your question.…
I don’t own any Staccato’s but I own a few STI’s that preceded them. The 5.4” Stacatto XL probably cycles a little slower and is a little more front heavy then the shorter guns. Longer then 4.6“ slides don’t seem to be in fashion on LO guns but I believe it won't slow you down much. I believe a Stacatto or MPA in a similar configuration can shoot nearly as good as a Vudoo, Atlas or Infinity. You might need to have more trigger work and spring tuning done on the less expensive gun to get it where you want it. You might be more likely to need to send the less expensive guns back to get reliability issues fixed. One advantage to cheaper guns is people seem more likely to modify them to suit their preferences such as changing springs, magwells,triggers, safeties, sights, dremeling the grip etc. which probably is more of a benefit then the qualities the more expensive gun gives. it might be worth keeping an eye out for a used Titan or Athena.
 
#17 ·
Thank you everyone for your feedback, I appreciate it. Right now I think I'm going to Try my staccato XL this weekend at a local match. If I was smart, I would just use that and call it good. But as most of us addicts here know and do, there'll be something new to my safe in their future.
 
#22 ·
Hard to go wrong with a priest for the money. I love mine. That said, thinking a shadow 2 trigger is slowing you down is just crazy talk. Wanting a new gun is fine we all like shiny new things but thinking its going to instantly change your times is the wrong train of thought. I switched maybe 6-8 months ago to 2011s and I'm not finishing as well as I did with my caniks lately. The main difference is I was training a lot more before with the caniks and now life has gotten into the way and im barely training at all. A "better" gun is not a sub for training there are people absolutely killing it with shadows in LO. Again I support you wanting a new gun but just be honest with yourself going into it. Want want it because its a new toy not because it will make us better.

Now to answer your question better. I jumped in the 2011 thing straight to the deep end. in about 6 months or so ive had a staccato P, STI tactical, 2 prodigy's I've done all the things too, a vudoo and 2 akais. also shot my buddies atlases, shot and worked on a buddies MPA. What ive learned mostly is that price doesn't really translate into performance. the Atlas were largely disappointing, i'm sure ill get **** on for that comment but thats my opinion. Nice guns great fit and finish but they shot just OK to me. The akais were great but again not twice as great as my vudoo or even the supped up prodigy as far a PERFORMANCE goes. Yes way better quality guns but it just doesn't really translate into score. I was also disappointed in my buddies MPA small things keep breaking on it and he's had to send it back a few times as well as ive had to swap his trigger since the shoe just broke off mid stage. If you're looking at it purely from a competition stand point vudoo is I think the best option.
 
#23 · (Edited)
Hard to go wrong with a priest for the money. I love mine. That said, thinking a shadow 2 trigger is slowing you down is just crazy talk. Wanting a new gun is fine we all like shiny new things but thinking its going to instantly change your times is the wrong train of thought. I switched maybe 6-8 months ago to 2011s and I'm not finishing as well as I did with my caniks lately. The main difference is I was training a lot more before with the caniks and now life has gotten into the way and im barely training at all. A "better" gun is not a sub for training there are people absolutely killing it with shadows in LO. Again I support you wanting a new gun but just be honest with yourself going into it. Want want it because its a new toy not because it will make us better.

Now to answer your question better. I jumped in the 2011 thing straight to the deep end. in about 6 months or so ive had a staccato P, STI tactical, 2 prodigy's I've done all the things too, a vudoo and 2 akais. also shot my buddies atlases, shot and worked on a buddies MPA. What ive learned mostly is that price doesn't really translate into performance. the Atlas were largely disappointing, i'm sure ill get **** on for that comment but thats my opinion. Nice guns great fit and finish but they shot just OK to me. The akais were great but again not twice as great as my vudoo or even the supped up prodigy as far a PERFORMANCE goes. Yes way better quality guns but it just doesn't really translate into score. I was also disappointed in my buddies MPA small things keep breaking on it and he's had to send it back a few times as well as ive had to swap his trigger since the shoe just broke off mid stage. If you're looking at it purely from a competition stand point vudoo is I think the best option.
Wow, as someone who's been debating an MPA or Vudoo, this is quite the indictment in MPA. Vudoo won nationals last year, MPA won this year. So either gun has the performance needed to win, and beyond most of our capabilities.

I've read multiple threads about mpa issues, mostly from older generations. But I've yet to hear any issues about quality from Vudoo. Which is a bummer because I was leaning more towards MPA.
 
#28 ·
I have two MPA's. One is the LO version for USPSA. The other is the IDPA compliant version.

I probably have 20k through the USPSA gun. About 5k through the IDPA gun.

ZERO problems with either.

MPA customer service has been phenomenal; both pre-sale and post.
I have subsequently sent MPA multiple questions about possible future purchases.
All emails have been answered in detail within 24 hours.
Some of my emails have been answered on a Saturday and Sunday as well.
I am sold on MPA. 100%.
 
#32 ·
So I use the atlas artemis for LO, but have tried out my priest for Open as I have it ported and wanted to shoot it at my local match for fun. My times and accuracy were pretty much the same, but i did notice the vudoo priest (and probably with all 5 inch slides pistols) was slightly sluggish compared to the Artemis 4.6 inch slide. Did it make a difference to me-no since I dont shoot fast enough for it to matter.
If I had to buy one gun for LO, i would definitely go with the priest for the price and the accuracy/fit of the parts was on par with the atlas. Also, in my opinion, the hybrid grip is the best grip that is a non V2 atlas grip that uses replaceable side panels.
 
#33 · (Edited)
For the money the MPA Ds9 can’t be beat IMO.

I have an Island barrel xl with a steel cheely grip and love it but the factory ds9 feels softer. It’s now going to my main and the XLi will be playing back up.

A buddy has an Athena and while it’s nice I like the way the ds9 and XLi cycle and return much better.

I handled a priest at a match but didn’t get to shoot it. Fit was about the same as my ds9. Would like to try one

I do want to try a sight block gun like the new ds9 LOCv2 or an Artemis though
 
#34 ·
I was glad when the came out with limited optics because I had this XL in 9 that I didn't know what to do with. I was shooting my XL in 40 for limited major but now I've got something to do with that silly 9. I kind of wish the allowed two divisions in a match like our IDPA matches do cause the use the same gear, for IDPA I shoot two XC's.