1911 Firearm Addicts banner
121 - 129 of 129 Posts
Discussion starter · #121 ·
WOW! You guys have the MISINFORMED, on this forum also.
Hmmm...

Against my good conscience, I’ll pretend for a half minute that you’re not just trolling and ask you what experience you have with the revolvers in question.

Any at all?

On what basis do you feel the Colt Python is superior to an MR73? Opinions are fine, just curious.
 
I do not know the twist rate precisely, but I have copied a chart from one of Michael Zeleny (Lavartus)'s excellent and comprehensive articles on the MR-73...he used to be on this blog and contributed his incredible knowledge about European hand guns periodically...I know he has a new ?daughter, and I suspect she occupies his time and energy now....Jack Bachelor (bac1023) is another source for information on these revolvers, and he has an equally incredible knowledge that he used to share with us..but again, I have not read a note for him in some time...but either of these two gentlemen would know the precise answer to your question....I have two MR-73 6" Match revolvers from the Mulhouse factory, and they are spectacular...so, from my information: 6 grooves with the rifling as mentioned below...hope that helps....BTW, I'd love to find a MR-88 but I have not had any luck thus far; I'm currently chasing a MR-96 on GB....see what happens with that...simply, you cannot go wrong with any revolver from Manurhin...Perry

Image
 
I do not know the twist rate precisely, but I have copied a chart from one of Michael Zeleny (Lavartus)'s excellent and comprehensive articles on the MR-73...he used to be on this blog and contributed his incredible knowledge about European hand guns periodically...I know he has a new ?daughter, and I suspect she occupies his time and energy now....Jack Bachelor (bac1023) is another source for information on these revolvers, and he has an equally incredible knowledge that he used to share with us..but again, I have not read a note for him in some time...but either of these two gentlemen would know the precise answer to your question....I have two MR-73 6" Match revolvers from the Mulhouse factory, and they are spectacular...so, from my information: 6 grooves with the rifling as mentioned below...hope that helps....BTW, I'd love to find a MR-88 but I have not had any luck thus far; I'm currently chasing a MR-96 on GB....see what happens with that...simply, you cannot go wrong with any revolver from Manurhin...Perry

View attachment 575359
Thanks for the chart. I've read through most of Michael Zeleny's writings. I found a place where he wrote the following:

Standard MR73 barrels are rifled with six grooves, with a right hand twist at a one turn in 476mm rate, replicating Smith & Wesson’s traditional rate of one turn in 18¾". Match barrels utilize five grooves at the same twist rate, with a bore diameter of 9.05mm. Up to serial number 39200, the bore diameter of standard MR73 barrels measures 8.96mm +0 / +0.03mm. After it, the barrels are finished to the .38 Match bore size, measuring 9.04mm +0 / +0.05mm. Handloaders can and should adapt their projectiles to the actual bore diameter. The barrel logo appears on the right in early production, then moves to the left in all its Mulhouse and Chapuis successors.

Kinda sounds like up to number 39200 the MR73 bore was really tight while the Match bore was closer .356". But the first sentence sound contradictory to the chart posted above where an MR73 357 bore is 400mm twist (15.75"). I've reached out to Manurhin last month but they haven't responded, nor does Kebco know either.

How does the grip to feel compared to a S&W L/K frame? Trigger position feel similar?

I'm torn between buying an MR38, or the MR73 HB or Match (both specials for Kebco)... I appreciate the help!
 
....BTW, I'd love to find a MR-88 but I have not had any luck thus far; ...simply, you cannot go wrong with any revolver from Manurhin...Perry

View attachment 575359
I disagree with the statement but I have shot Manurhin revolvers since the 1980s and have owned a MR88. The early MR73s had problems with the piano wire rebound spring that slipped and rendered the gun useless until reinstalled. Manurhin changed the design later.

The MR88 is a six-shot version of the Ruger SP101 and the trigger is nowhere like the triggers on the various MR73s that I have shot over the years. The MR73 is a nice classic target revolver but so is the Korth Sport, S&W 14 / 19 and the Colt Python.

The S&W14 still holds the revolver Bullseye record in this country, with Korths and Manurhins being rarely seen at competitions. In Germany there is no competition on a county level without at least a Korth or Manurhin present.
 
121 - 129 of 129 Posts